صادق خادمی

وب‌سایت مرکزی
وب‌سایت مرکزی SadeghKhademi.ir خانه صفحه اصلی چت آرشیو آثار منابع و تحقیقات ارتباط با ما فرم تماس
در حال بارگذاری ...
منوی دسته بندی
← BACK TO LIBRARY

Elucidation of the Concept of Escape in Mystical Spiritual Practice

Critical Analysis and Explication of the Chapter on Escape in Manzil al-Sirn

Excerpted from the lecture series by Nokounam (Session 116 Chapter on Escape Part Four).

Preface

The chapter on escape, as one of the prominent stations in the path of mystical spiritual journey in the noble text Manzil al-Sirn authored by Khwja Abdullah Ansr, constitutes a pivotal locus directing the seeker towards profound inner and outer transformation. This section, focusing on three foundational axes of escapeflight from ignorance to knowledge, from inertia to vitality, and from constriction to expansivenesselucidates the necessity of dynamism in both individual and social existence. The present lecture, adopting a critical and profound perspective, addresses the cultural, social, and scholarly conditions of religious seminaries and the Islamic society at large, emphasising the imperative of knowledge production, active endeavour, and dynamic reliance upon the Divine.

Section One: Explicating the Concept of Escape in Mystical Progression

The Threefold Axes of Escape

Escape in mystical progression constitutes a journey through which the seeker is guided from the existential darkness towards the illumination of gnosis, dynamism, and liberation. This station encompasses three cardinal axes: fleeing ignorance towards knowledge, abandoning inertia for vivacity, and breaking free from constriction into openness. Each axis corresponds to a dimension of the human beingintellect, volition, and heartengaged in the reconstruction of perfection.

Key Point: Escape in mystical progress is a tripartite journey that leads the seeker from ignorance to knowledge (cognitive transformation), from inertia to vitality (motivational transformation), and from constriction to expansiveness (emotional and existential transformation). These metamorphoses constitute the foundational pillars of the movement towards the Ultimate Truth.

This tripartite categorisation resonates profoundly with the sacred verse فَفِرُّوا إِلَى اللَّهِ (Adh-Dhriyt: 50; : So flee to God). Escape towards the Truth represents the ultimate objective of the spiritual journey, actualised through the transformation of the existential dimensions of the human being. The flight from ignorance denotes liberation from the darkness of unawareness and the embracement of the radiance of knowledge; escape from inertia signifies the awakening of the will and the vitality of the spirit; and fleeing constriction entails the opening of the chest to Divine light and release from existential anxieties.

Determinants of Backwardness and Advancement

The factors precipitating individual and social backwardness are encapsulated within the triad of ignorance, inertia, and constriction, whereas the determinants of progress manifest as knowledge, vitality, and expansiveness. This duality offers a criterion for assessing the state of the seeker and society along the spiritual path. A closed society is mired in ignorance, lethargy, and anxiety, while an open society is characterised by awareness, enthusiasm, and magnanimity.

Key Point: The factors of backwardness (ignorance, inertia, constriction) stand in stark opposition to the factors of advancement (knowledge, vitality, expansiveness). This dichotomy provides a psychological and sociological framework for analysing human and societal conditions and underscores the necessity for transformation within cultural and social structures.

This perspective serves as a mirror reflecting the inner and outer condition of the human being. The seeker must, through contemplation of these factors, facilitate their passage from darkness to light. A society immersed in ignorance, enveloped by lethargy, and confined within the anxieties of constriction, is incapable of progressing towards perfection.

Characteristics of Closed Individuals and Societies

Closed individuals and societies are ensnared by ignorance, inertia, and constriction. These attributes manifest within their minds, hearts, cultures, and social relations, obstructing spiritual progression and advancement. Such individuals, due to a lack of openness and awareness, fall prey to self-imposed limitations and social confinements, as if imprisoned within a cage of their own making.

Key Point: Closed individuals and societies are trapped within the cage of ignorance, inertia, and constriction. This state impedes spiritual and social flourishing, obstructing the seekers movement towards the Truth.

This description functions as a critique of the psychology of closed individuals and the sociology of closed societies. A closed mind resists acceptance of truth; a closed heart is deprived of love and openness; and a closed society wallows in anxiety and unrest.

Order and Vitality in Spiritual Progress

Inertia signifies a spiritual malaise that impedes the seekers advancement. The remedy lies in establishing order and vitality within ones life. Discipline in acts of worship, study, and activity functions as a life-giving current, directing the seekers spirit from lethargy towards dynamism.

Key Point: Order and vitality constitute the cure for spiritual inertia. This principle aligns with the verse إِنَّ الصَّلَاةَ كَانَتْ عَلَى الْمُؤْمِنِينَ كِتَابًا مَوْقُوتًا (An-Nis: 103; : Indeed, prayer has been decreed upon the believers a decree of specified times), emphasising the importance of order in worship.

Order, as the backbone of the spiritual journey, guides the seeker from dispersion to focus and dynamism. Vitality acts as a refreshing breeze that purifies the seekers heart from the dust of inertia and prepares them for endeavour and movement.

Section Two: Critique of Spiritual Distance and Misinterpretation of Religious Concepts

The Spiritual Gap between Ordinary Humans and Divine Saints

The vast disparity in spiritual status between ordinary human beings and the Divine saints has engendered misunderstanding and misinterpretation of religious teachings. This gulf acts as a profound chasm that obstructs proper utilisation of religious knowledge and entraps the seeker in passivity and misconception.

Key Point: The spiritual distance between ordinary humans and Divine saints results in misinterpretation of religious concepts and impedes the correct benefit from religion.

This breach functions like a barrier separating the seeker from the light of truth. When erroneous understanding supersedes correct gnosis, religion becomes an instrument of passivity and lethargy instead of guidance.

Criticism of the Misinterpretation of Tawakkul (Trust in God)

Tawakkul, when misunderstood, is equated with passivity and laziness, whereas its true essence embodies active endeavour combined with reliance upon God. Tawakkul signifies entrusting the outcome to God subsequent to exertion, not a passive expectancy of provision.

Key Point: Genuine tawakkul is inseparable from effort and trust in God, harmonising with the verse وَمَنْ يَتَّقِ اللَّهَ يَجْعَلْ لَهُ مَخْرَجًا وَيَرْزُقْهُ مِنْ حَيْثُ لَا يَحْتَسِبُ (At-Talq: 2-3; : And whoever fears God He will make for him a way out and will provide for him from where he does not expect).

Tawakkul is a bridge connecting human endeavour to Divine grace. Its misinterpretation leads the seeker towards inertia and fruitless anticipation, whereas authentic tawakkul calls one towards exertion and creativity.

Tawakkul and Production

True tawakkul is accompanied by reflection, effort, and production. Piety and knowledge enliven the intellect, culminating in invention and discovery. This process leads to unexpected provision, as if a spring gushes forth from the depths of the earth, quenching all thirsts.

Key Point: Tawakkul is an active and creative process that, through the production of knowledge and deeds, culminates in unexpected provision. This perspective aligns with the verse وَيَرْزُقْهُ مِنْ حَيْثُ لَا يَحْتَسِبُ (At-Talq: 3).

Production is the fruit borne of the tree of knowledge and piety. The seeker, through endeavour and contemplation, not only nourishes themselves but also benefits others with the bounty of their existence.

Section Three: Critique of the Culture of Mendicancy and the Imperative of Knowledge Production

Criticism of the Culture of Mendicancy in Religious Seminaries

The culture of mendicancy and passivity prevalent in religious seminaries hinders the production of knowledge and the dignity of scholars. A scholar ought to be, instead of dependent, a producer and self-sufficient, akin to a spring that gushes forth from itself and quenches others.

Key Point: The culture of mendicancy deprives scholars of dignity and authority. The scholar must achieve self-sufficiency and serve society through the production of knowledge.

This critique serves as a warning to religious seminaries to extricate themselves from passivity and advance towards productivity and vitality. The scholar is like a farmer who, by sowing knowledge, nourishes not only themselves but the entire society.

The Necessity of Global Knowledge Production

Religious seminaries must engage in knowledge production across all scientific disciplinesfrom philosophy and mysticism to psychology and politicsstandardise such knowledge, and present it to the world. This process elevates seminaries from passivity to scientific authority.

Key Point: Knowledge production within seminaries leads to the globalisation of religious sciences and scientific competitiveness. This process elevates scholars to positions of dignity and authority.

Knowledge production is a jewel whose radiance illuminates not only the seminaries but the entire world. Through the production of knowledge, the scholar transforms from a consumer into a creator of value.

Decline of Seminaries Attributed to the Absence of Competition

The absence of scientific competition and motivation within seminaries inexorably leads to the decline of elite intellectual forces and pervasive lethargy. Competition functions as a vital breeze, invigorating the hearts with motivation and thereby fostering growth and flourishing.

Key Point: Scientific competition acts as a catalyst for advancement. Its absence engenders stagnation and decline within seminaries, whereas its presence propels growth and intellectual blossoming.

Competition may be aptly likened to a contest that summons scholars to exertion and innovation. In the absence of such motivation, seminaries become ensnared in repetition and inertia.

Section Four: Lethargy, Alertness, and Openness

Lethargy and the Commanding Self (Nafs Ammara)

Lethargy is a hallmark of the nafs ammara (the commanding self), manifesting as weakness and passivity. To escape lethargy entails surmounting the self and advancing toward vitality as if the spiritual seeker awakens from the slumber of heedlessness and steps resolutely toward the light of exertion.

Key Point: Lethargy is emblematic of the nafs ammara, intimately connected to the Quranic verse
وَنَفْسٍ وَمَا سَوَّاهَا فَأَلْهَمَهَا فُجُورَهَا وَتَقْوَاهَا (Ash-Shams: 78; translation by Fooladvand: "By the self and Him who fashioned it and inspired it [with discernment of] its wickedness and its righteousness").

The nafs ammara acts as a snare, entrapping the seeker in lethargy and heedless slumber. Deliverance from this snare is attainable through piety and diligent effort.

Alertness (Tashmir) and Vitality

Tashmir denotes vitality, earnestness, and maturity in ones spiritual journey. This state propels the seeker from lethargy toward profound spiritual and practical awakenings, as if their soul has been liberated from the shackles of inertia and soars toward dynamic movement.

Key Point: Tashmir signifies dynamism and earnestness in the spiritual path, guiding the seeker toward spiritual and practical surges.

Tashmir resembles a current that conveys the seeker from the shore of lethargy into the ocean of endeavour and dynamism. This state is characterised by readiness for action and progression.

Chest Constriction and Sustenance (Rizq)

The constriction of the chest refers to anxiety concerning sustenance for oneself and ones family. Liberation from this constriction leads to the opening of the chest and trust in divine provision, as though the seekers heart transitions from the darkness of anxiety to the light of assurance.

Key Point: The opening of the chest relates to the verse
أَلَمْ نَشْرَحْ لَكَ صَدْرَكَ (Ash-Sharh: 1; translation by Fooladvand: "Did We not expand for you your breast?") and signifies emancipation from the narrowness of sustenance-related anxiety.

The opening of the chest serves as a key that unlocks the prison of worry, guiding the seeker toward tranquility and reliance upon God.

Section Five: Knowledge, Reliance, and Practical Exemplars

Knowledge: The Most Precious Commodity

Knowledge represents the most valuable asset capable of securing both material and spiritual sustenance. The production of knowledge culminates in the self-sufficiency and dignity of scholars, akin to a precious gem the depths of effort and contemplation.

Key Point: Knowledge is the most precious commodity that, through generation and innovation, bestows honour and authority upon scholars.

Knowledge is a treasure that not only enriches its possessor but also liberates society from spiritual and material impoverishment.

The Exemplary Case of Imam

Imam epitomises an eminent scholar who attained dignity and authority through the production of revolutionary thought and action, independent of material sustenance. Through reliance on God and persistent endeavour, he attained unexpected provision and lived humbly.

Key Point: Imam exemplified active reliance and scholarly dignity through the production of thought and praxis.

He shone like a celestial star in the firmament of mysticism and praxis, guiding society toward transformation through creativity and perseverance.

Critique of the Fox and Lion Parable

The tale of the fox and the lion offers a critique of a misconstrued interpretation of reliance. Reliance implies becoming like the lion (a producer), not the fox (a passive consumer). The seeker must turn away from passive expectancy toward productivity and creativity.

Key Point: Reliance denotes productivity and creativity rather than passivity and idle expectation, just as the lion produces whereas the fox consumes.

This narrative functions as a mirror reflecting the true nature of reliance, summoning the seeker toward exertion and dynamism.

Tamhil and Problem-Solving

Tamhil signifies resourcefulness and the pursuit of creative solutions to challenges. This concept pertains to production and innovation, not deceit or cunning, as though the seeker, through creativity, unties the knots of existence.

Key Point: Tamhil represents creative problem-solving that, through effort and innovation, leads to the resolution of spiritual and material issues.

Tamhil is a key unlocking closed doors, guiding the seeker toward intelligent and effective solutions.

Sincere Hope (Raja) and Active Expectation

Raja denotes sincere hope rooted in effort and labour, not passive expectation of aid from others. This hope is accompanied by productivity and movement, propelling the seeker toward dynamism.

Key Point: Raja is active hope based on endeavour, not passive greed founded on begging.

Raja serves as a lamp illuminating the path of exertion, guiding the seeker from the darkness of greed toward the light of action.

Unexpected Sustenance

Unexpected sustenance refers to sublime and unforeseen provisions obtained through production, invention, and discovery. This sustenance resembles a treasure unearthed through effort and creativity.

Key Point: Unexpected sustenance emerges from creative and unforeseen pathways, connected to the Quranic verse
وَيَرْزُقْهُ مِنْ حَيْثُ لَا يَحْتَسِبُ (At-Talaq: 3).

Such sustenance is akin to a spring that gushes forth from the earth, nourishing not only the seeker but society at large.

Section Six: Summary and Conclusion

The chapter on escape in Manazil al-Sa'irin, emphasising the three axes of departure from ignorance to knowledge, from lethargy to vitality, and from constriction to openness, guides the seeker toward inner and social transformation. This station critiques the culture of begging and passivity within seminaries and underscores the necessity of knowledge production, active endeavour, and dynamic reliance. Reliance serves as a bridge connecting human effort with divine grace and, through contemplation and creativity, culminates in unexpected sustenance. Quranic verses such as
وَمَنْ يَتَّقِ اللَّهَ يَجْعَلْ لَهُ مَخْرَجًا (At-Talaq: 2) constitute the foundation of this transformation. The exemplar of Imam manifests a scholar who attained honour and authority through the generation of thought and action. Seminaries must strive for global stature through knowledge production in philosophical, mystical, psychological, and political domains.

Supervised by: صادق خادمی