Excerpts from the Lectures of Nokounam, (Session 249)
Introduction
Within the spiritual path of mystical progression, tawakkul (trust in God) occupies a foundational station among the exalted ranks of wayfarers. This station, which reaches its pinnacle among the elect, not only redefines the relationship between the human and the Divine Sovereign but also provides an existential and manifest framework for apprehending the bond between the Ultimate Reality (aqq) and creation (khalq). The present lecture, session 249 of Manzil al-Sirn, undertakes an in-depth analysis of the concept of special tawakkul and the reciprocal relationship of agency and principalhood between the Divine and creation.
Section One: Special Tawakkul and the Certainty of the Elect
Special
tawakkul denotes a lofty degree of trust in which the wayfarer attains a profound certainty that all affairs ultimately return to God. This certainty finds its root in the comprehension of the sublime verse:
الْأَمْرُ كُلُّهُ لِلَّهِ
(Srah l Imrn, 3:154, Translation: "All matters belong to God")
The most noble and perfect of humansthose addressed in the verse:
لَيْسَ لَكَ مِنَ الْأَمْرِ شَيْءٌ
(Srah l Imrn, 3:128, Translation: "You have no say in this matter")
realise that no true sovereignty resides in human agency except that which is exercised as a delegated authority from God.
Special tawakkul is a certainty guiding the wayfarer to apprehend the Divine dominion over all existential and actual spheres. This certainty does not negate human agency but affirms the existential dependence of human action upon Divine Will.
This understanding acts as a beacon illuminating the path of spiritual progression, leading the seeker from the darkness of self-centricity towards the light of existential dependency. The absence of autonomous authority in human agency does not imply denial of human efficacy; rather, it expresses that every act and existence ultimately depends on Divine Will and grace.
Section Two: The Relationship of Agency and Principalhood
In special
tawakkul, a reciprocal and dynamic relationship between the Divine (
aqq) and creation (
khalq) is established. God, as the principal (
muwakkil), is the originator of all affairs, while human beings, in the role of agents (
wukal), enact the Divine Will. Simultaneously, humans are also principals and God the agent, since the manifestation of creation equally depends upon Divine grace. This reciprocal interplay resembles a harmonious dance between two parties of an existential bond wherein creation is recognised as the manifestation of the Divine, and God as the primordial source of existence.
The relationship of agency and principalhood constitutes an existential dialectic that affirms human agency within the framework of Divine grace, while emphasising God's sovereignty as the ultimate principal.
This relationship is akin to a mirror that reflects the image of Divine existence in creation, yet the mirror itself depends on Divine light to shine. Such a view defines tawakkul as a reciprocal and dynamic relationship in which neither party is wholly annihilated nor utterly independent.
Section Three: The Rejection of Determinism in Special Tawakkul
Special
tawakkul is incompatible with fatalistic determinism. Humans, in their capacity as agents, exercise active efficacy, yet all their actions depend upon Divine grace. The noble verse:
وَمَا رَمَيْتَ إِذْ رَمَيْتَ وَلَٰكِنَّ اللَّهَ رَمَىٰ
(Srah al-Anfl, 8:17, Translation: "And you did not throw when you threw, but God threw")
clearly elucidates that human action is exercised by delegated authority from God, not inherently on its own.
The negation of determinism within special tawakkul underscores human volition and activity within the domain of Divine grace. The human is an agent, yet the primary efficaciousness belongs to God.
This concept is analogous to a bow whose string is drawn by human hands, but the power propelling the arrow emanates from God. This vision liberates the human from the bonds of fatalism and presents him as an active participant in the Divine path.
Section Four: Existence and Manifestation in the Spiritual Path
In the descending phase (
nazl), creation manifests the Divine Reality, while God remains the Absolute Existence. Conversely, in the ascending phase (
d), creation is the manifestation, and God is the Originator of manifestation. This relation negates determinism and presents creation as the Divine manifestation rather than an independent entity. This framework resembles a river flowing from the Divine source of existence and returning towards the same origin during ascent.
The relationship between existence and manifestation confirms the existential unity of Divine Reality and creation, preventing dualism or independence of creation.
This perspective considers creation as a shadow whose existence depends upon Divine light. Within this framework, special tawakkul acts as a bridge between descent and ascent, guiding the wayfarer towards unity with the Divine.
Section Five: The Companionship of Divine Reality and Creation
The elect are those who comprehend the companionship of Divine Reality and creation. God is with man, and man is with God, yet this companionship neither annihilates creation nor grants it independence. This relation is akin to two companions walking a shared path, each preserving their own station and role.
The companionship of Divine Reality and creation expresses unity amidst multiplicity, wherein creation is the manifestation of Divine Reality and God is the origin of existence, accompanying each other in the path of spiritual progression.
This companionship resembles a breeze that moves a leaf, yet the leaf retains its identity. The wayfarer neither perceives himself as annihilated nor separated from the Divine but moves in harmony with the Divine command.
Section Six: Critique of the Perspective of Muy al-Dn Ibn Arab
Muy al-Dn Ibn Arab likened the world to fanciful images in a mirror and attributed
tawakkul to illusions. This view has been critically examined, as it reduces creation to an illusory and unreal entity. In contrast, the present lecture regards creation as the manifestation of the Divine Reality, possessing a subtle reality inherently connected to Divine existence.
Creation is the manifestation of the Divine Reality, not a fanciful illusion. This viewpoint affirms the authenticity of creations manifestation and its connection to Divine existence.
This critique acts as a light dispelling the darkness of illusions and reveals the truth of creations manifestation in the radiance of Divine existence. Creation is not a shadowy image in a fanciful mirror but a subtle and connected manifestation of the Divine Reality.
Section Seven: Fundamental Principles of Existence and Manifestation
Two fundamental principles in the philosophy and mysticism of this lecture are proposed: first, Divine Reality is existence, and creation is manifestation; second, creation is action, and Divine Reality is essence and agent. These principles offer a unitive framework for understanding the relationship between Divine Reality and creation and resolve all philosophical and mystical issues therein.
The principles of existence and manifestation confirm the existential unity between Divine Reality and creation, preventing duality or independence of creation.
These principles resemble two wings enabling the wayfarers flight in the sky of gnosis. Divine Reality, as absolute existence, is the source of all, and creation, as manifestation, lacks independent essence. This framework defines tawakkul as an existential and manifest relationship.
Section Eight: The Analogy of Tawakkul as a Contract
Tawakkul is likened to a contract in which the human pays part of the cost, and the major portion is provided by God. This analogy tangibly demonstrates the cooperation of human agency and Divine grace.
Tawakkul represents the partnership of human agency as the agent and Divine grace as the principal, negating determinism and affirming human efficacy.
Analytical Discourse on Divine Agency and Trust (Tawakkul)
This metaphor resembles a marketplace wherein human endeavour procures a share, while God, by His infinite grace, provides the remainder. This collaboration transforms trust (tawakkul) into a dynamic and proactive pathway.
Section Nine: Refutation of Fatalism as a Political Superstition
Fatalism has been introduced as a political superstition propagated by tyrannical caliphs for the purpose of societal control. God is not a despot; rather, He is a gracious and restorative agent who rectifies affairs.
Key Point: Fatalism is an imposed and fallacious viewpoint. God, as the Restorer (al-Jbir), is a rectifier and regulator of affairs, not an oppressor.
This perspective is akin to liberation from imposed chains, emancipating humankind from the captivity of fatalism, thereby guiding them toward volition and active agency within the Divine path.
Section Ten: The Meaning of Al-Jbir in the Divine Names
The Divine Name
Al-Jbir signifies the mender and reformer, not a tyrant. God resembles a physician who breaks a misaligned bone and resets it, thereby restoring order.
Key Point: God's attribute as Al-Jbir denotes the correction and regulation of creations affairs, not coercion or tyranny.
This interpretation is like a luminous beacon that unveils the true meaning of the name Al-Jbir, distancing it from fatalistic misapprehensions. God is the Guide and Restorer who accompanies creation on the path to perfection.
Section Eleven: Trust (Tawakkul) as the Most Precise Path
Should trust (tawakkul) be construed as the complete negation of human volition, it devolves into the weakest of paths, for it renders agency meaningless. Conversely, in this paradigm, trust constitutes the most precise path (
adduq al-subul), establishing a dynamic and reciprocal relationship between the Divine and creation.
Key Point: Particularised trust, as the most precise path, affirms human agency within the framework of Divine grace, whilst eschewing the negation of volition or fatalism.
This perspective serves as a key that unlocks the intricate barriers of spiritual conduct, guiding the seeker towards a luminous and exact route. Trust is not the denial of agency, but its affirmation under the auspices of Divine will.
Section Twelve: Trust as a Shared Relationship
Trust (tawakkul) is a shared relationship in which the Divine and creation participate conjointly in existence and action. God, in His aspect of Being, is both the Attorney and the Principal, and creation, in its manifestation, is likewise both Attorney and Principal.
Key Point: The shared nature of trust indicates a unity of existential and functional reality between the Divine and creation, which is neither dualistic nor monistic.
This relationship is comparable to a garden where the trees of creation draw sustenance from the soil of Divine existence, whilst simultaneously exhibiting beauty through their branches and foliage. Particularised trust manifests this shared reality in a profound and precise manner.
Conclusion
The lecture series
Manzil al-Sirin (Session 249), with its focus on particularised trust (tawakkul kh), offers a profound and coherent framework for understanding the existential and manifest relationship between the Divine and creation. The elect, by certitude in the injunctions:
al-amru kulluhu lillh
(All affairs are entirely God's) laysa laka mina al-amri shay
(You have no share in the affair)
attain a reciprocal relationship of agency and delegation. This relationship repudiates fatalism whilst affirming human agency within Divine grace. The principles of existence and manifestation, as a foundational framework, avert duality between the Divine and creation and define trust as a shared and dynamic relationship. The critique of Muy al-Dn Ibn Arabs viewpoint and the negation of fatalism as a political superstition underscore the primacy of creations manifestation and the active role of humanity in spiritual progression. Particularised trust, as the most precise path, guides the seeker towards accompaniment with the Divine command. Supervised by: Sadegh Khademi