صادق خادمی

وب‌سایت مرکزی
وب‌سایت مرکزی SadeghKhademi.ir خانه صفحه اصلی چت آرشیو آثار منابع و تحقیقات ارتباط با ما فرم تماس
در حال بارگذاری ...
منوی دسته بندی
← BACK TO LIBRARY

Manzil al-S'irn: Elucidation of the Third State of Intimacy and the Revealing of Truth in Mystical Journeying

Lecture Series of (May his soul rest in peace) Session 432

Introduction: A Journey through the Realms of Intimacy and Truth

In mystical journeying, the path of the traveller (s'ir) is akin to a voyage that leads them from the external to the internal, from outward appearances to the essence, and from selfhood to the Divine. Within this journey, the stage of intimacyparticularly the Third Intimacy (انس ثالث)holds a unique and elevated position. It is a precious gem that guides the seeker to the contemplation of the divine radiance and the unveiling of truth, without the need for symbolic pointers. This article, drawing upon the lecture series of (May his soul rest in peace), in session 432, offers a profound and scholarly explanation of the Third Intimacy, its characteristics, and its pivotal role in mystical pathwork. The Third Intimacy is a state wherein the traveller transcends the limitations of symbolic guidance and attains a direct apprehension of the divine majesty. However, the blending of this state with the essence itself may lead to conceptual confusion. This text, through the critique of narrow perspectives (as exemplified by the "Karmi" view) and the advocacy of a holistic perspective (as represented by the "Mhi" view), provides an epistemological framework for a deeper understanding of the mystical journey.

Section One: Conceptualising the Third Intimacy in Mystical Pathwork

Definition of the Third Intimacy: The Revealing of Divine Radiance

The Third Intimacy, as outlined in the lectures, is described as the unveiling of the divine radiance without any symbolic reference, because it has no limit and cannot be pointed to directly. This definition introduces the Third Intimacy as a transcendent stage of the journey, where the seeker, free from any form of defined or restricted reference, directly witnesses the divine grandeur. The divine radiance (سبحات جلال) represents the majestic manifestations of the Divine that purify the heart of the traveller from attachment to anything other than the Divine.

Key Point: The Third Intimacy is like a window through which the seeker beholds the infinite light of divine majesty directly, without the intermediary of symbols or limitations.

Distinction between Intimacy and Truth: The Necessity of Conceptual Order

The lecture series critiques the conflation of intimacy (انس) and truth (حقیقت), stressing that the core focus should be on intimacy rather than truth itself. This critique highlights the necessity of logical order in the elucidation of mystical stages. Truth, as a general and overarching existence, encompasses all beings, while intimacy is a specific stage of perception and closeness to the Divine. Confusing these two concepts leads the traveller to conceptual fragmentation and deviation from the proper path.

And whomever is granted wisdom has been given an abundant good. (Quran, Surah Al-Baqarah, 2:269)

This sacred verse underscores the significance of wisdom in maintaining intellectual order and avoiding the conflation of concepts.

Stages of Intimacy: From Symbols to Truth

Intimacy in the mystical path comprises various stages, beginning with intimacy through symbols, progressing to intimacy through the light of revelation (نور الکشف), and culminating in the Third Intimacy, which leads directly to the witnessing of the divine radiance. The Third Intimacy is a stage where the traveller transcends the limitations of symbolic references and definitions, achieving direct perception of the divine grandeur. This stage is distinct not only from intimacy through symbols, but also from intimacy through the light of revelation, as it signifies the travellers liberation from any epistemic intermediary.

Summary: The Third Intimacy is a transcendent stage in the mystical path, guiding the seeker to the direct perception of divine grandeur without the need for symbolic reference. The distinction between intimacy and truth maintains the intellectual coherence of the mystical framework and prevents conceptual fragmentation. This stage occupies a pivotal place within the system of mystical stations and requires a precise and systematic understanding.

Section Two: Critique of Epistemological Methods and Pathological Analysis of Mystical Journeying

Critique of Textual Analysis Methods: Focus on Fundamental Errors

The lecture series critiques reductionist methods of textual analysis in mystical literature, asserting that critique should focus on fundamental errors (such as distinctions between the letters "Sd" and "Sn") rather than superficial details or exaggerated expressions. This perspective presents a pragmatic approach to textual critique, rescuing the study from unnecessary length and fragmentation. By focusing on the central themes, the seeker is guided toward a deeper understanding.

Key Point: Mystical text analysis is akin to polishing a precious gem; it must address the substantial flaws, not trivial surface scratches.

Critique of the Notion of Limit: Degrees Instead of Boundaries

The lecture series rejects the claim that truth or intimacy is without boundaries. Instead, it emphasizes that beings possess degrees, rather than limits. Boundaries are attached to specific essences, while degrees refer to the existential and epistemic determinations. The Third Intimacy, as a defined degree, is subject to unveiling and reference, unlike truth, which transcends boundaries and definitions.

Levels of Beings: Creational and Epistemic

Beings possess both creational degrees (determinations of the Divine) and epistemic degrees (intellectual and psychological perceptions of these manifestations). In this framework, the Third Intimacy is an epistemic degree, leading the traveller to witness the divine radiance.

Critique of Claims Such as "Cannot Be Pointed To" and "Cannot Be Grasped in Essence"

The lecture series deems claims like "cannot be pointed to" and "cannot be grasped in essence" for intimacy as erroneous. Intimacy, as a defined degree, is indeed subject to both reference and perception, in contrast to truth, which exceeds limits and essence. This critique underscores the importance of focusing on the main subject (intimacy) and avoiding discussions unrelated to the essence.

Critique of the Claim "When It Appears, Nothing Remains Except It"

The lecture series critiques the claim "when it appears, nothing remains except it," asserting that while God is the manifest One, the creations continue to exist. The notion of otherness (غیر) is not one of estrangement, but rather refers to the divine manifestations. This perspective, rooted in the doctrine of the unity of existence (وحدت وجود), explains the relationship between the Divine and creation as one of appearance and reflection.

He is the Manifest and the Hidden. (Quran, Surah Al-Hadid, 57:3)

This verse emphasizes the appearance of the Divine in the world and the continued existence of creations as divine manifestations.

Unity of Existence: The Divine and Creation, Manifest and Reflective

The lecture series, doctrine of the unity of existence, considers the world as devoid of any true otherness. Creation is the manifestation of the Divine, not an independent entity. This principle provides a philosophical framework for understanding the Third Intimacy, wherein the witness perceives this unity in the realm of divine grandeur.

Critique of Essence-Seeking: Attainment of the Essence, Not Its Comprehension

Critical Study: The Essence of Spiritual Paths and Religious Education

Critique of Scrutiny: Pessimism from the Worm's Viewpoint

The discourse criticizes the individuals prone to excessive scrutiny, accusing them of adopting the viewpoint of a worm, focusing solely on negative details. This myopic perspective leads to an inherent tendency towards pessimism and fault-finding. Such behaviour not only causes psychological harm but also diverts the seeker (Slik) from the path of spiritual progression.

Higher Perspective: Intuition of Divine Wisdom

The higher perspective sees the world as delightful and beautiful. As emphasized in the discourse, referencing the mystical poem, "The world is delightful because it derives its delight from Him," this view is rooted in the acceptance of divine wisdom. It directs the Slik towards satisfaction and the perception of the cosmic order.

Lower Perspective: The World as Hell

The lower perspective sees the world as filled with flaws and troubles. The discourse compares this view to hell, highlighting the detrimental effects of the pessimism generated by the worm's viewpoint. This perspective deprives the Slik of perceiving divine wisdom and leads them toward dissatisfaction.

Wisdom of Nature's Decay: Divine Balance

The discourse elucidates divine wisdom through the example of the falling of blossoms. What appears as a flaw in the worm's perspective is, from the viewpoint of the fish, a necessary element that sustains the balance and health of nature. This metaphor invites the Slik to a deeper understanding of divine wisdom.

Summary

The worm's view and the fish's view represent two opposing perspectives in the spiritual journey. The former leads to limitation and pessimism, while the latter leads to comprehensiveness and transcendence. The discourse critiques the worm's view and advocates for the fish's perspective, guiding the Slik towards the perception of divine wisdom and the beauty of the cosmos.

Section Four: Pathologies in Religious Seminaries and the Seminary Life

Critique of Religious Seminaries: Structural Weakness

The discourse draws an analogy between religious seminaries and the fragile sheet metal, stressing the structural weaknesses and inefficacy of these institutions. Due to the worm's perspective and their limited goals, seminaries lack the necessary strength to produce influential and profound scholars.

Key Point: The Weakness of Religious Seminaries

Religious seminaries are compared to a fragile building, which, without intellectual and spiritual support, is incapable of producing great scholars.

Materialistic Goals of Seminary Students: Limitation and Materialism

The discourse accuses seminary students of having narrow and materialistic goals (such as reciting mourning rituals or giving sermons). These goals divert them from the original mission of seminary life, which is to serve the faith and pursue the truth, leading to inefficacy.

Authentic Seminary Life: Principle and Secondary Matters

Authentic seminary life regards the seminary as the primary pursuit and life itself as secondary. The discourse critiques the transformation of seminary life into a mere pursuit of monetary gain and materialism. A seminary student must dedicate their life to the service of religion and avoid pursuing trivial goals.

Quranic Reference: "Follow the Path of One Who Turns to Me" (Luqman: 15)

This verse from the Holy Quran emphasises the need for adherence to the principles of truth in authentic seminary life.

Need for Strengthening: Reinforcing the Foundations

The discourse calls for religious seminaries to reinforce their intellectual and spiritual foundations. Just as a building requires solid structural support, seminaries must strengthen their foundation to produce scholars of influence. This metaphor suggests the need for fundamental reforms in the seminaries' educational system.

Analogy of Religious Seminaries as Fragile Buildings

The comparison of seminaries to a building without walls or beams emphasizes the lack of intellectual and spiritual stability. This critique highlights the structural weaknesses within religious seminaries and their inability to produce great scholars.

Cultural Critique of Qom: Lack of Infrastructure

The discourse highlights the lack of cultural infrastructure in Qom, such as cinemas, stressing the city's limitations in fostering intellectual and cultural development. This absence has led to cultural isolation and an inability to nurture great scholars.

Recommendation to Larger Cities: Broader Horizons

The discourse advises students to pursue their studies in larger cities. These environments, by providing broader horizons, contribute to intellectual and spiritual growth.

Summary

Religious seminaries, due to their structural weaknesses and the worm's perspective, have been unable to produce great scholars. Authentic seminary life, prioritizing faith over material concerns and reinforcing intellectual and spiritual foundations, offers a pathway for reforming these institutions.

Section Five: The Third Union, the Realm of Vision and Transcendence

The Third Union: Immediate Vision of the Divine Majesty

The third union represents the realm of direct, unmediated perception of the divine majesty, which renders any intermediary or conceptualisation unnecessary. This stage is like a pinnacle from which the Slik gazes upon the grandeur of the Divine and transcends the limitations of knowledge.

Key Point: The Third Union as a Mirror