Key Point: Revelation vs. Mystical Experience
The concept of revelation is protected from any distortion or fault due to the infallibility of the prophets, while mystical experiences, due to the potential for error, are considered of a lower rank. The heart, as the primary vessel for receiving revelation, operates without the mediation of the senses.
The Levels of Prophetic Infallibility
Infallibility of the prophets is defined in four aspects:
- Infallibility in Reception: Prophets are immune from error when receiving revelation from the unseen.
- Infallibility in Conveying: In transmitting the revelation to the community, they deliver exactly what they have received without any omission or addition.
- Infallibility in Action: Prophets are immune from sin and disobedience and do not err in their actions.
- Infallibility in Senses: The senses of the prophets are free from error and mistake, even in the physical world.
These four dimensions of infallibility demonstrate the prophets perfection across all aspects of their existence. Just as stars in the sky guide the way, prophets are flawless not only in receiving and transmitting revelation but also in their actions and sensory perceptions.
Critique of Sadoughs View on Prophetic Forgetfulness
Sadough, in his discussion of prophetic forgetfulness (sahw al-nabi), has suggested the possibility of error in the senses of prophets. This viewpoint is critiqued because one who is immune from error in receiving and transmitting revelation cannot be subject to error in their senses. Infallibility, as a pervasive flow throughout all aspects of a prophets being, encompasses the senses as well. Just as a skilled driver is incapable of misjudging the road, a prophet, in all their high and low stations, remains free from any fault.
Miracle and Acceptance of the Truth
A miracle is a divine sign that transcends the senses and human knowledge, leading people towards accepting the truth. Accepting a miracle is akin to accepting a gateway to the unseen realm, signifying acceptance of the divine message, revelation, and the truth of God. A miracle does not arise from human knowledge nor depend on ordinary means; it is a divine gift issued from the heart of the prophet, guiding the hearts of people toward the truth.
Second Conclusion
The heart, as the primary vessel for receiving revelation, plays a unique role in mystical progression. Revelation, due to the infallibility of the prophets, is distinguished from mystical experience and remains immune from any distortion. The infallibility of the prophets in receiving, conveying, acting, and sensing demonstrates their perfection. The miracle, as a divine sign, paves the way for guiding people towards the truth. These discussions establish theoretical foundations for understanding mystical experience and its place in the mystical journey.
Section Three: Mystical Experience, Adherence, and Falling
Definition of Mystical Experience
Mystical experience is akin to an intimate, internal encounter between two friends, a secret exchange between two inner beings, in which a truth from the unseen realm is revealed without any veil. This vision occurs in a realm beyond the material, without the need for physical presence. Mystical experience means "becoming non-existent and reaching a state of unveiling," just as the seeker, with the eye of the heart, attains the vision of divine truths beyond the veil of knowledge. The Qur'an describes this state by referring to the heart as the vessel of understanding: Have they not traveled through the land, so that they may have hearts by which they understand? (Al-Hajj: 46).
Mystical Experience between Creator and Creation, or Between Two Humans
Mystical experience may occur between the Creator and the created, or between two individuals. This connection is formed in a non-material realm, where the inner beings, like two mirrors facing each other, reflect one another and exchange secrets. The seeker, with their heart, is capable of hearing voices, receiving news, and achieving direct insight into divine truths.
Adherence and Falling: Two Stages of the Mystical Path
The mystical journey encompasses two distinct stages: adherence (tadani) and falling (tadalli). Adherence is the veiled stage, dependent on the world of imagination. At this stage, the seeker may witness superficial forms, but these forms, like shadows in Plato's cave, are far from the truth. Adherence, due to its connection to the material world, often obstructs progress, diverting the seeker from their true path, much like a child distracted by toys. However, falling (tadalli) is the stage of complete unveiling, where the seeker, like a bird released from its cage, reaches direct vision of divine truths. This stage, which represents the return from unity to distinction, sees the seeker transcend the veil of knowledge and attain the station of direct vision. Falling is the stage in which the divine saints reside, having reached complete unveiling.
Obstacles in the Mystical Path during Adherence
Adherence, because of its dependence on the world of imagination, often hinders the seeker from continuing their journey. The apparent forms in this stage, like mirages in the desert, deceive the seeker, causing them to become stagnant rather than progressing. The seeker may, out of excitement, claim spiritual stations or, like a self-proclaimed guide, attempt to lead others. However, the divine saints avoid such traps and refrain from making claims. They remain silent and unwavering, like a steadfast mountain, giving witness to divine truths without assertion.
Vision of Fixed Divine Realities
Mystical experience encompasses not only the vision of the fixed divine realities in the essence of truth but also the ability to receive information from all divine realms. The seeker can receive truths from the eternal tablet, the clear book, or other realms of existence. This vision, like celestial observation, may originate from any station or realm. Mystical experience, as a mode of informational transmission, guides the seeker towards direct, unveiled guidance, while falling represents the pinnacle of this unveiling.
Third Conclusion
Mystical experience, as a unique form of vision, guides the seeker towards direct reception of divine truths without any veil. Adherence, due to its connection to the world of imagination, acts as an obstacle, while falling leads the seeker to the stage of complete unveiling and direct vision. The saints, by avoiding claims and distractions, pass through the obstacles of adherence and attain the station of falling. Mystical experience, with its ability to perceive divine realities and realms, opens a gateway to the truth.
Overall Conclusion
The stages of the mystical path, akin to a radiant lamp illuminating the way, guide the human soul towards ultimate perfection. The current discourse, by clarifying the two existential vessels of the human being, the role of the heart in receiving revelation and mystical experience, and the differences between adherence and falling, offers clear theoretical foundations for Islamic mysticism. The heart, as the vessel of unique perfection, is not only the abode of revelation but also the center of mystical vision and the mystical path. Revelation, through the infallibility of the prophets, is distinct from mystical experience and represents the highest station of receiving the unseen. Adherence, due to its dependence on the material realm, obstructs the path, while falling leads the seeker to complete unveiling and divine vision. This writing, with its comprehensive and refined content, serves as a valuable source for researchers and seekers of truth in the field of Islamic mysticism. Supervised by: Sadegh Khademi